Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

OBESITY ALONE MAY NOT BE PROTECTED BY ADA

Written on .

Obesity remains a controversial issue under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).  Employers received some relief from the issue in a recent court ruling that obesity unaccompanied by an underlying physiological condition is not a disability protected by federal law.  Richardson v. CTA, No. 17-3508 (C.A. 4, 6/12/19); see also Aumara v. Monsanto, 2019 BL218595 (E.D. La., 6/13/19) (even if morbid obesity is an impairment, plaintiff cannot show his weight substantially limits major life activity).  In this case, plaintiff was a severely obese bus driver with the Chicago Transit Authority.  The Authority contended that the plaintiff's weight exceeded the limit of the driver's seats and made it difficult for him to operate the bus pedals properly.  The court found that the employer thus had non-discriminatory reasons for the termination.  More importantly, the court joined three other federal appeals courts in finding that obesity unaccompanied by an underlying physiological condition simply isn't protected.  The court saw weight as a physical characteristic just like eye and hair color, not a disability. 

Editor's Note:  While the Second, Sixth and Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has reached results similar to that of the Seventh Circuit in the Richardson case, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the First Circuit have issued rulings indicating that obesity alone could be protected from discrimination.

Related Content

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.

Recent Content

In today's litigious environment, proactive compliance is not just good practice—it's essential for survival. This webinar is designed to e…
sand timer
The Trump Administration has acted to terminate TPS status for several countries. Of course, litigation has followed each notice of termina…
honduras
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has not issued a Federal Register notice to terminate the Temporary Protected Status (TPS) design…
handcuffs, money
President Trump had told federal agencies to consider civil rather than criminal enforcement of their regulations, in an executive order da…
fire employee sad, figurine
President Trump has attempted to extend his authority over federal agencies that previously operated somewhat outside of direct White House…
you are lying, note
Employers have to make a lot of decisions in the workplace, including the famous “he said-she said” issue involving the investigation of se…