Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

JOKES ABOUT AGE FORCE EMPLOYER TO FACE AGE DISCRIMINATION TRIAL

Written on .

A 43-year-old head of sales was hired by a start-up internet technology company, and was employed only three months before being terminated for failing to meet sales quotas. At only 43, he was the oldest employee in the company, as most employees in the start-up company were in their 30's. The Defendant employer's chief executive made a remark to Plaintiff that he needed "to get in shape to keep up with us young guys," and later referred to Plaintiff's hernia as an "old man injury" and said, "Look what happens when you try to keep up with the thirty-year-olds."

While normally a 43-year-old would not seem to be a good candidate for an age-discrimination case, particularly when hired at the same age just three months earlier, in this case the discriminatory remarks were made very close to the date the decision was made to terminate the Plaintiff, and the court found that a reasonable juror would find that the employer viewed Plaintiff as falling into a different age category than other employees and believed this inhibited his ability to perform in a fast-paced start-up environment. Consequently, the court denied the employer's motion for summary judgment and found that, while the comments were said to have been intended as jokes, whether they demonstrated discriminatory animus was for a jury to decide.

Editor's Note: This case demonstrates how discriminatory comments can come back to "bite" an employer, even where the comments may be intended as jokes. The judge even quoted Shakespeare's King Lear, in which we read: "Jesters do oft prove prophets." While courts often find such comments to only be "stray remarks," sometimes they are considered as evidence of discriminatory motivation. The case is Brown v. Crowdtwist, 122 F.E.P. Cases 846 (S.D.N.Y. 2014).

Related Content

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.

Recent Content

Jacmel Bay, Haiti
A federal judge in the Eastern District of New York has ruled on a motion for partial summary judgment that the Department of Homeland Secu…
in loving memory memorial, outdoors
With great sadness, we announce that our esteemed colleague and friend, Mark Allen Waschak, departed this life on June 27, 2025.  He was…
heat visual
The U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) announced that it is moving forward on a public hearing over the Biden-Era he…
racial equality, printed, typewriter
In an extremely important development, on April 23, 2025, President Trump issued an executive order declaring:  “It is the policy of the Un…
checkmark
E-Verify+ is a new tool that streamlines the employment eligibility verification process for employers and new hires. 
colored paint patterns
Guidance from the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued on March 19, 2025…