Opinion: Responding to a Plaintiff Attorney’s Demand Letter
When employees are represented by attorneys, it is common for such plaintiffs’ attorneys to send a “demand letter” to the employer. Such letters make impressive demands and expressly give the employer the “opportunity” to negotiate settlement without litigation. How should the employer respond?
There are several options to the employer, including ignoring the demand, providing a short response denying violation of the law, and giving a detailed response and possibly even some proof. There are pros and cons of each approach.
Some employers worry that a failure to respond at all suggests to others that the claims are true. On the other hand, the employer is to some extent “bound” by its response, because if the employer gives inappropriate reasons or later changes the reasons offered, the plaintiff will contend that such changes show a pretext and discrimination. The employer’s response also gives plaintiffs information to perfect or improve their claims.
In this writer’s opinion, the best answer to the dilemma must be decided on a case-by-case basis. At a minimum, however, it is suggested that the employer’s attorney make a concise response denying the plaintiff’s claims, indicating that any further communications regarding a claim should be made to the employer’s attorney. Inasmuch as a legal claim has been made against the employer by virtue of the plaintiff’s letter, pertinent records must be preserved even though they would ordinarily be removed or destroyed under the employer’s record retention policies. Further, employers should begin an internal investigation of the claims while the evidence is still available and fresh.
This article is part of our November 2026 Newsletter.
Read the full analysis of recent employment law updates, federal policies, and workplace regulations.
Need experienced labor and employment counsel in Atlanta or nationwide? Explore Wimberly Lawson’s legal services or connect with our attorneys.
Related Content
Get Email Updates

Opinion: Responding to a Plaintiff Attorney’s Demand Letter

NLRB Guidance Memo Narrows Protected Activism

Republican NLRB Majority Makes First Shift in Labor Policies

DOL to Back Off Enforcing Laws in Unionized Workplaces

What the Democratic Sweep Means
