Republican NLRB Majority Makes First Shift in Labor Policies
The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB or Board) has changed its policies in situations in which employee outbursts pertaining to legitimate employer policies also contain some type of protected activity.
An earlier ruling during the Biden Administration called Lion Elastomers found an employer violated the Labor Act in disciplining a worker for his part in a confrontation during a safety meeting. It set forth three standards used for specific settings: one applying to employee interactions with management, another governing picket-line interactions, and a third involving social media posts and most cases involving employee conversations in the workplace. These tests required employers to give leeway for workers to exercise their protected rights during labor disputes that get heated. It has been applied to finding labor act violations when employees wrote “Whore Board” on an overtime sign-up sheet, shouting racist taunts at striker replacements, and posting on social media that a manager is such a “nasty m------ f-----.”
The result is that the current NLRB, with its new 3-member Republican majority, will begin applying a different test known as the Wright Line test. This test applies when the NLRB accuses employers of punishing workers for taking Labor Act-protected actions, such as raising safety concerns, and employers claim they could act for legal reasons in taking these actions. Under the Wright Line test, the NLRB must first make out a case that the employer punished the worker for a protected action, and then the employer gets a chance to show it would have done the same thing even if the worker had not taken the protected action.
Editor’s Note
While applying the Wright Line test for employee misconduct in such situations is good news for employers, the rationale used by the new NLRB was controversial, in that it did not directly over-rule the earlier Lion Elastomers ruling, but instead followed a circuit court of appeals 2024 ruling setting aside that case. The new test and case is Lion Elastomers LLC, Case 16-CA-190681 (9/23/26).
This article is part of our November 2026 Newsletter.
Read the full analysis of recent employment law updates, federal policies, and workplace regulations.
Need experienced labor and employment counsel in Atlanta or nationwide? Explore Wimberly Lawson’s legal services or connect with our attorneys.
Related Content
Get Email Updates

Opinion: Responding to a Plaintiff Attorney’s Demand Letter

NLRB Guidance Memo Narrows Protected Activism

Republican NLRB Majority Makes First Shift in Labor Policies

DOL to Back Off Enforcing Laws in Unionized Workplaces

What the Democratic Sweep Means
