Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

The Latest      —

SUPREME COURT RULING ON ARBITRATION POLICIES LIMITING CLASS ACTIONS FURTHER SHOWS MORE LIMITED APPLICATION OF PROTECTED CONCERTED ACTIVITY DOCTRINE

Written on .

In Epic Systems v. Lewis, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that employers could require mandatory individual employment agreements with employees that require individual arbitrations rather than any type of class or collective actions.  Plaintiffs had contended that such limits on class and collective actions interfered with their protected concerted activity to bring such actions.  Instead, the Court in a 5-4 majority ruled that concerted activity was limited to actions that are "more directly involved with organizing and traditional bargaining."

Most commentators caution about over-reading the Supreme Court ruling, however, as it applied the rationale for what happens in legal proceedings once you get there.  It does not apply to employees banding together to discuss or prepare for joint action on employment issues.  Some have interpreted the case as supporting the right of employers to contract whatever they want in their individual arbitration agreements with their employees.

The significance of the case is shown by fact that there were hundreds or thousands of federal and state lawsuits on hold awaiting the result of the ruling.  Many of the cases were wage-hour collective actions, and judges had agreed to suspend the lawsuits pending the outcome of the Supreme Court ruling as to whether the cases could proceed as class or collective actions, or had to be referred to individual arbitration.

Various studies indicate that by 2017, over 56% of private-sector non-union workers were subject to mandatory arbitration agreements.  The issue has become particularly more controversial recently as some womens’ rights groups suggest individual arbitration makes it more difficult for women to pursue sexual harassment claims. 

Related Content

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.

Recent Content

office, desk, papers
The Trump Administration has succeeded in terminating TPS status for people from several countries. This update provides information about…
desk, paperwork and a used office
In May, the Trump Administration finalized a rule permitting low-premium, high-deductible plans in the ObamaCare exchanges, and allowing th…
two people talkingin a warehouse
In June, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) voted to replace a Biden-era enforcement plan for one that establishes emp…
corridor, bathroom door for women
The EEOC just resolved a sex discrimination and retaliation charge where the EEOC accused a municipality of not providing a sex-specific lo…
desk, office, calendar
According to announcements from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) in October, the EEOC has reduced the time period for emp…
deskt, door, notepad
When employees are represented by attorneys, it is common for such plaintiffs’ attorneys to send a “demand letter” to the employer. Such le…