Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

Music at Work Claimed to Create a Hostile Environment

Written on .

According to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, sexually explicit music played in the workplace can create a hostile environment in violation of Title VII.  Harp v. S & S Activewear, LLC, 69 F. 4th 974.  Eight former employees (seven women and one man) charged the warehouse allowed "sexually graphic, violently misogynistic" music to be played loud such that it permeated the workplace.  The workers also claimed that the music encouraged male employees to make sexually explicit remarks, engage in sexually graphic gestures, and the like.  The defense was rejected that the music did not constitute discrimination since all employees were exposed to the music, and that both men and women were offended by it.  The Eleventh Circuit has previously issued a similar ruling, and the Second Circuit has found that a hostile work environment be created where "sexually offensive comments and graffiti" were commonplace.

The lesson from these type rulings in that employers must police their workplace to maintain its appropriateness, and inappropriate behavior or speech that denigrates people on the basis of a protected class potentially create a legally actionable hostile environment claim regardless of whom it offends.  The court particularly found fault that the employer continued to allow the music to be played because managers felt it motivated employees to work harder, and management had ignored complaints from employees related to the music.

This article is part of our February 2024 Newsletter. 

View newsletter online

Download the newsletter as a PDF

Related Content

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.
texas flag
Congress passed a law in both Houses under the Congressional Review Act to reject the new National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) Joint Emp...
gaza on a map
While the death of George Floyd ignited one round of protest, the Gaza situation has created another such round of protest.  As a general...
pendulum
Some polls suggest that many employees desire their employers to take public positions on political/social issues.  As a result, employer...
filing cabinet handle
In a new "first," the EEOC has sued more than a dozen employers for not filing required reports that include the racial and sexual makeup...
submitting ballot into box
The United Auto Workers (UAW) was once arguably the most powerful union in the U.S. Each of the "Big Three" U.S. car manufacturers were U...
an hourglass sitting on rocks outside
In a move long anticipated by many court watchers, the Supreme Court on June 28, 2024, jettisoned a longstanding doctrine of deference to...