Accessibility Tools

The Latest      —

What Does It Take to Create a Hostile Work Environment? Apparently, a Single E-Mail Will Do.

Written on .

How much harassment does it take to create a hostile work environment? You might be surprised – but then again, maybe not. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) just issued a ruling finding that a single e-mail is enough to support such a finding.

In Lashawna C. v. Perez (not the complaining party's real name), 2017 WL 664453 (Feb. 10, 2017), the EEOC concluded that the recipient of an e-mail containing an allusion to events that occurred more than 4000 years ago was sufficient to adversely affect "reasonable" person's work environment. This excerpt from the opinion tells the story:

At the time of events giving rise to this complaint, Complainant worked as a term Workers' Compensation Claims Examiner …. Complainant and [Supervisor S1 had] exchanged emails about Complainant's work hours and schedule. During the exchange, Complainant stated that government employees generally work shorter hours than private sector employees, and she was "working like a civilian." In response, S1 stated the following:

"Wow … then I must be a damn fool … cause I've been working like a Hebrew slave the last 9 years and don't have enough time to take off … at least somebody got it right."

… [W]e note that the word "Hebrew" is often used to refer to Semitic persons who identify as descendants of Abraham, the biblical patriarch of Judaism. Moreover, when used to generally refer to contemporary Jewish persons, it is sometimes considered archaic or offensive. Coupled with the word "slave," the term "Hebrew slave" is particularly negative and offensive when used so flippantly. As such, we find that the use of the term "Hebrew slave" is inherently unwelcome when uttered in this particular context, especially when communicating with a Jewish person. There is no evidence that Complainant welcomed such a comment. Therefore, we find that S1's comment was unwelcome…. [I]t is [also] apparent that the term ""Hebrew slave" pertains specifically to Jewish persons, and as such, is inherently based on religion…. (emphasis added)

Based on that one statement, the EEOC determined that a reasonable person in Complainant's circumstances would find that S1's comment was severe enough to create a hostile work environment based on her religion. And the EEOC found that the AJ's award of $10,000 is supported by substantial evidence and that the AJ's award of attorney's fees in the amount of $10,980 is supported by substantial evidence.

There you go. No tangible discrimination, no adverse job action, no other offensive statements, no other evidence or anti-Semitism. The EEOC concluded that this single allusive reference to the Book of Exodus constituted religious harassment – to the tune of more than $20,000.

We should note that most cases aren't this extreme. This was a decision authored by the EEOC, not a Federal court. Courts usually apply more stringent standards when they evaluate harassment claims. A Supreme Court justice famously observed that the civil rights laws weren't meant to impose Victorian sensibilities on the American workplace. Most courts would likely dismiss the e-mail discussed above as a "stray remark," especially if it only occurred once.

This decision will likely become notorious for its conclusion that taking offense on this scale to a single e-mail message was the reaction of a "reasonable person." Again, this is the EEOC's conclusion: courts generally impose a more stringent, "objective" standard that requires more than an individual's subjective perception of the words or conduct.

This is a cautionary tale for everyone: be careful when you indulge in a colorful analogy to make a point.

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.

Recent Content

paying for item, indoors, business

Pay Gains Are Shrinking

Everyone can feel the high inflation levels that have been plaguing the U.S. over recent months.  Recent data indicates the high inflatio...
notebook, pencil

Recent Ruling Limits At-will Provisions of Employee Handbook

Most employers have employee handbooks, and most employers have done a pretty good job of including at-will statements therein and statem...
bee hive, outdoors

If You Have a Company Intranet Site, Read This

Many employers have company non-public intranet sites allowing employees to communicate with the company and each other on matters of int...
covid 19 virus, concept

Benefit Adjustments When COVID-19 Emergency Ends

The Biden administration has announced that the COVID-19 emergency will end May 11, 2023.  Employers should prepare now for changes that ...
holding a be the good mug, indoors

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished... but Sometimes the Do-gooder Is Vindicated

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit just held - shock alert! - that paying an employee more than is legally required does ...
promo graphic for Strategies for Coping with Labor Shortages

Where Have All the Workers Gone? Strategies for Coping with Labor Shortages

The declining workforce participation is resulting in job vacancies almost double the number of available employees.  This webinar will e...
  • Home
  • Articles
  • What Does It Take to Create a Hostile Work Environment? Apparently, a Single E-Mail Will Do.

Wimberly, Lawson, Steckel, Schneider & Stine

3400 Peachtree Road, Ste 400 / Lenox Towers / Atlanta, GA 30326 /404.365.0900

Where Experience Counts


Thank you for visiting the firm's website. Please note that this website is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute an offer of representation or create an attorney-client relationship with the firm. The firm welcomes receipt of electronic mail but the act of sending electronic mail alone does not create an attorney-client relationship. You may reproduce materials available at this site for your own personal use and for non-commercial distribution. All copies must include the firm's copyright notice.

© Wimberly, Lawson, Steckel, Schneider & Stine P.C. | Site By JSM