Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

TRUMP’S "STRAY REMARKS" HAVE DOOMED HIS IMMIGRATION EXECUTIVE ORDERS

Written on .

What do the court decisions on the Trump Administration’s executive orders banning entry by certain immigrants have to do with discrimination law?  It turns out the answer is "a lot."  The main objections to Trump’s executive order is that his words as a presidential candidate were used to show that the travel ban may be an unconstitutional religious test for entry into the U.S.  Among other things, in a press release it was announced he was "calling for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States."  As a result of various court injunctions, the President attempted to issue a second executive order explaining that his first order was not a "Muslim ban," but was intended to apply to territories and to protect the nation from foreign terrorist entry into the U.S.  Although the new executive order did not refer to any religion, the plaintiffs in various litigation are arguing that it nevertheless was religiously motivated. 

The main issue in most employment discrimination cases is whether there was a discriminatory motive for the employer’s conduct in adversely affecting a plaintiff or group of plaintiffs.  Sometimes the employer seems to have a valid reason for the matter, such as a termination, but remarks are made by certain supervisors indicating a discriminatory motive.  For example, if a decision maker in a layoff should be quoted as saying, "That old fart should have retired." such a statement by a decision maker is treated almost like an admission of guilt, as evidence of age bias.  On the other hand, statements by supervisors outside of the decision-making process are often to considered to be "stray remarks," not sufficient to show discriminatory bias on the part of the decision-maker. 

In any event, these immigration cases show how decision makers’ casual remarks are often taken seriously by courts.  

Related Content

Get Email Updates

Receive newsletters and alerts directly in your email inbox. Sign up below.

Recent Content

deskt, door, notepad
When employees are represented by attorneys, it is common for such plaintiffs’ attorneys to send a “demand letter” to the employer. Such le…
NLRB Guidance Memo
Oftentimes workers engaged in that one might call political activism, and are restricted or disciplined in doing so by their employer. Some…
office desk, blue collar
The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB or Board) has changed its policies in situations in which employee outbursts pertaining to legitim…
Editorial documentary photograph
In a New York University Conference on Labor and Employment Law, Labor Solicitor Jonathan Berry said the Department of Labor (DOL) continue…
democrat donkey symbol, usa
Legal Alert • Labor & Employment On Tuesday, November 3rd, the tsunami brought Democrats to power not only in both houses…
november webinar promo graphic
The Obama Administration changed the long standing Wage Hour Interpretative Bulletin concerning joint employment and independent contractor…